I've read two things recently and though they were written a
continent and a decade apart, somehow my head has put them together.
The first is an article by the great writer Verlyn
Klinkenborg that appeared in Sunday's "New York Times." It's
called "The Decline and Fall of the English Major."
The second is by British ad legend Robin Wright. It was
published in "Campaign" back in 2003 and was titled "Would David
Abbott Get a Job in Advertising Today." In the interest of
full-disclosure, I came across this piece in Ben Kay's excellent blog. You can
read his post by clicking here.
Both Klinkenborg and Wright bemoan the disparagement or,
more dramatically, the dearth of good writing.
Klinkenborg has this to say about teaching writing to
college and graduate school students at some of the top colleges and
universities in the United States. "They
can assemble strings of jargon and generate clots of ventriloquistic syntax.
They can meta-metastasize any thematic or ideological notion they happen
upon... But as for writing clearly, simply, with attention and openness to
their own thoughts and emotions and the world around them — no."
Wright says of the 2002 D&AD Annual,
"But today, Writing for Advertising is a thin joke when we
actually look at what has been selected by the eminent jury. Most of the ads
selected for this "writing" category have no text. And of those that
do, in an unconscious but real demotion of the relevance of words, the words
are displayed in such a way that none of the text is actually legible."
In short, it seems to me that both men lament the “passing
of writing.” And both men seem to attribute the passing to simply being out of
fashion. Klinkenborg notes that the number of English majors at prestigious
universities has declined precipitously. At Pomona College, one of the nation’s
elite schools, just over 1% of the student body are English majors. And the
number of English majors at Yale are down from 165 in 1991 to just 62 in 2012.
Here’s where I net out.
Most brands cannot state simply, clearly and in a compelling
manner what business they’re in. What makes them different and worth
considering. We live in a world where few people have brand preferences because
99% of all communications do a crappy job at articulating those preferences.
Back on September 5th, when Obama was nominated
to run for a second term, Bill Clinton delivered a 3,100 word speech telling
viewers what this nation and Obama were about.
You can read the speech and my post on the speech here.
There was no technology involved.
Not even any graphics.
But there was warmth, humor, humanity.
And it moved people.
It changed opinion.
It got people to act.
There are scads of people who would like to say writing is
dead. Maybe because it’s hard and they can’t do it. Maybe because they don’t
consider it cool. Maybe they believe thought can be outsourced. Maybe because real writing and real thought is expensive.
I happen to believe otherwise.
What's expensive is not finding the right words.
Because I happen to believe words matter.
No comments:
Post a Comment