Monday, November 16, 2026

Part the Ninth of Twelve.



This Humanment might seem more of a joke than a firm principle. People have been writing in symbols since the Lascaux caves about 22,000 years ago, around the last time anyone anywhere did something honest. Picture writing was all the rage among the Pharaonic-set, and for longer than most people can fathom Cuneiform was the lingua franca of the civilized world.

There's nothing, really, inherently wrong with symbolic writing. The leap to alphabets involved symbols too. Only symbols of phonemes--sounds--rather than objects. Rather than a sketch of an ibis, we drew shapes that could represent the sound the word ibis.

 ✂✂✂✂✂✂✂✂✂Clip and forget. ✂✂✂✂✂✂✂✂✂✂

The problem I have with emojis can be found--as most things can--within Orwell's great essays, "Politics and the English Language." In that piece which, if you care at all about honest communication you will read, print out, and save on your hard-drive, Orwell lists six rules for good writing. They don't precisely link up to emojis, but give me a few seconds to explain why I make the connection.

In his 1949 novel, Nineteen Eighty-four, Orwell creates a language called Newspeak. To limit a person's ability to think critically, Newspeak restricts vocabulary, limiting people's ability to articulate with nuance and express abstract concepts. In his appendix (the part of a book, not your anatomy) Newspeak is characterized by a continually diminished vocabulary and contractions. (Not child-birth contractions. Think cognates like Gestapo, Ice, Maga and Doge.)

Limited vocabulary results in limited expressions. Much of today's epidemic of outrage comes from the population no longer having strata of words that allow an escalation toward anger or violence. In many walks of life we move quickly from:

'I disagree' to
'I hate you' to
'I'm going to kill you, muthafukker.'
That's every fight I've ever had with a cab-driver or every subway contretemps I've ever witnessed and run from.

That is trumpism in thirteen or fourteen words, depending on whether or not you consider muthafukker one or two words.

Here is one more example:
'I believe we should tax trillionaires' to
'You Sharia-law-amerikkla-hating communist' to
'Insurrection in Washington.'

Emojis, to be clear, are not the stain of trumpism. But they are a high-occupancy-vehicle lane on the superhighway to Newspeak.

Going back to Orwell's first rule above, 'Never use a metaphor, simile or other figure of speech which you are used to seeing in print' we are all too used to seeing praying hands, smiles, piles of shit in our communications. If you want to really get through to readers, you might work a little harder and try to be interesting rather than expected.

I worked, briefly with a talented art-director for a time who had but two words to describe an idea he liked, "sick," or "dope."

After a day working with him, I went home looking for a methadone clinic.


Herman Kahn, a 1960's-era physicist, military-strategist and employee of the RAND Corporation, created a 44-step escalation ladder to help the world avert nuclear war. Imagine, in a time of limited political skill, intelligence, historical language and thinking, how many fewer steps there might be today before missiles or drones start flying. Someone might, for instance, start a war so people don't find out he raped 14-year-olds.

Of all the inhuman things humans can do, using an emoji or an occasional LOL aren't really that egregious.

This Humanment is included as a warning.

To watch our words.

To understand their power.

To think about how to use them for effect.

And to be mindful of what happens when we stop questioning the meaning behind language and how it is used. From Newspeak, to Goebbel's (and roy cohn's and trump's) Big Lie, to Lingua Tertii Imperium, Viktor Klemperer's great book on the malevolent use of language in Nazi Germany, then Soviet Germany, to be human is to question. 



And questioning takes thoughtful examination and expression. As Klemperer reminds us, "resistance to oppression (political or employment or marital) begins by questioning the constant use of 'buzzwords.'  Think about phrases like 'the Patriot Act,' 'Agentic,' (software replacing people) or such strident bushwa as this, 'WPP Open turns marketing into a continuous engine for growth. Powered by AI agents that work across your entire marketing process, connected by shared intelligence and guided by world-class talent.'

Thou Shalt Not Emoji because Thou Shalt Think.👏







Friday, November 13, 2026

The Carve Up.

Carve up today has nothing to do with your Thanksgiving turkey.

It's about history.

And how if you read history, you can learn a lot about the present.

That's the reason to learn history.

None of that Santayana bushwa, just common-sense.

While a lot of industry doyens send me their books on marketing--they usually want a blurb, and I'm happy to help--I don't read marketing books to learn about marketing.

I read books about the world to learn about the world.

I apply what I learn to marketing.

Ever since the beginning of time--or at least since about 12,000 years ago when many humans transitioned from hunting and gathering to agriculture and urban settlements, humans have claimed different territories.

They've moved into lands that weren't 'theirs.'

And via superior strategy, tactics, technologies or numbers they took that land as their own. 

Along the way they enslaved and looted.

And made themselves richer.

That's what humans do.


The Mongols, because of the stirrup, were steadier on their horses. That technology gave them an edge. They conquered and ruled the largest empire ever.

It's been estimated that today, one-in-two hundred men have the C3* cluster of genes. That is they are related, somehow, to the Mongols.


The Parthians or Achaemenids or the Sassanians or Persians did more than a little carving up too. If you ever heard the phrase "parting shot," it was originally "Parthian shot." The Parthians were such skilled fighters that could gallop north while shooting south. From such skills, empires are carved.


One of the issues with empires (and with not reading history) is that people assume the national or even the corporate divisions we're used to were ever thus. When they break down or collapse, we think that that signifies the end of the world, not the normal entropy of world events.

Here are a few historical snapshots of what today we call the Middle East.





Below, in color, is the Middle East most of us grew up with.

So we thought it was "right." Natural somehow.

It wasn't. Isn't.

It was a carve up designed by two men, Sykes and Picot.

And it never made much sense.



Today, there is so much tumult in the region, the current map might look like this:

Or like this.

With conflicts exploding everywhere all the time.


The essential point here is simple. And one you won't find in marketing books.

Carve-ups are ongoing.

And flux is ongoing.

Whether it's Coke versus Pepsi, Omnicom versus Publicis, or Blue versus Red. Assuming one's "right" to a certain domain as ordained or god-given is as dopey as expecting truth from a press-release or an agency 'town-hall.'

Right now, there's another world carve-up unfolding before our very eyes.

We don't even realize it's happening.

We don't even realize it's not artificial.

We don't even realize it ain't natural.

Four or five men, or ten or twelve men are carving up the world.

They're saying this belongs to me.

They're saying you belong to me.

They're saying you will make me richer.

They're saying you will accept my reality.

That's what the nazis did.

The romans.

The soviets.

The aforementioned mongols, parthians and more.



These companies have carved up your brain.

Your shopping habits.

Your contact with the outside world.

They've staked their claim to you.

Via a complicit press and corporate-enablers they tell you they're hegemons, and unassailable, about seventy-seven times a minute.

They pretend they're ordained and inevitable.

And that they'll last forever.

Ozymandias.

Ozymandias is a reminder.

I urge you to make either of these your ring tone.

I prefer the Gielgud over the Cranston.

But I'm old as basalt.

No, older.












Thursday, November 12, 2026

Part the Eighth of Twelve.




Back during my first stint at Ogilvy, basically before I knew which of the urinals in the men's room didn't squirt water when you flushed it, I was dragooned by then president Steve Hayden to rescue a dot com account that had been all-but "cooled" to death.

1999 was a more naive era. Many people, especially ad people, believed you could shoot gerbils out of a cannon in a commercial on national TV, and that would get you a billion-dollar valuation. 

Today, we are so much wiser, richer and more experienced. Now, all you have to do to win a trillion dollar valuation is lose $80,000,000,000 in half a year. Then, you can cash in like the founders of anthropic or some other 'I'm-not-sure-what-they-do-or-why-it-matters.'




In any event, I was grabbed by Hayden and locked in my nearly-padded office writing scripts twelve hours a day for a weekend for a now defunct dot com, which was riding high at the time, called PeoplePC.

(I still have 6000 shares of their stock. Which is worth as much as a tranche of hegseth-futures.)

The next thing I knew, I had sold a package of scripts and was sitting in a white van with Hayden and my art-director Susan Westre (whom at that point I had never even met) at 7AM one cold morning on our way to location in a small town called Bridge Mix, New Jersey.


I had nothing to do with the previous round of commercials, but you can be sure they followed the universal strategy that every creative team and agency has followed for about the last thirty years. We don't have to tell people what a product does, what makes it different, why someone might need it, we only have to tell people it's cool. This spot below has, since last century, been the universal default commercial for every product--no matter what it does or who the potential target is.


In any event we were out in Jersey shooting a bunch of spots and the dweeb of a client approached Steve Hayden. He was happy with how the shoot was going and happy with the spots.

"It looks like we have a hit on our hands," he blow-harded.

Steve nodded as if he had been listening.

The client continued, "Too bad the first round was such a disaster."

Steve took a step back and, quietly, said "If the first round hadn't been a disaster, we wouldn't be here."

That's the sort of thing you remember for thirty years. And think about every thirty minutes for thirty years.



Which brings me to the point of the eighth of my Humanments: Thou Shalt Get Lost.

Not get lost as I so often hear it, as "go fug yourself," but get lost as in take a risk. Meander. Let your mind wander. Take the longest distance between two points. Think different and differently.

You can read about the institutionalized lack of getting lost in today's world in a dense book I'd recommend called, "Boom: Bubbles and the End of Stagnation," by Bryne Hobart and Tobias Huber. 

You can buy it here, buy a machete here to cut your way through it, and read The Wall Street Journal review here. 

Boom is the kind of book, BTW, that people in agencies used to read when agencies existed to direct and steward clients' business, not just execute generic commoditized advertising. It's a brand-leadership book--not a mere marketing book. If people running agencies and holding companies still read, I'd call it a "must read." As it stands today and the fact that there's no influencer involved in it, it's a "must ignore." (That is, something not fed to you and everyone else by the reign of 'one algorithm fits all.')

The thesis of "Boom" is simple. 



In other words, all the agile-firsting, AI-tool-enabled, utilization-optimizing, six-sigma-black-belting, timesheet haranguing, briefing-by-eleven-first-tissue-by-three-ing, sprinting, brain-storming, efficiency-shibbolething, horse-hockeying nonsense is just that, nonsense.

More great work was done by people throwing pencils at the ceiling and kibbitz-thinking than all the algorithmic bushwa that the trillion-dollar-valuation sham-companies are spending trillions on forcing us to believe.


Why would anyone buy 'creative' from a company
that puts their name on something like this?
A. Says who?
B. I dunno, 'Think Different,' and 'Just Do It' are decades old and still relevant.
Not to mention Shakesepeare or the Bible. 
C. How has A.I. helped anyone in real-life?

I'd rather have six people from my personal ad group-chat take two hours and solve a brand issue than have AI do it. What's more, it would be funnier, more memorable, faster and cheaper. And we'd eat better, too. Pass the lo mein.

More and more we are following orders--the protocols edicted by McKinsey-inspired holding-company technocrats--telling us how to do things that they've never done and never will.

I'd rather get lost.

Good and lost.

And then come back with something I may get fired for.

Hopefully something that doesn't test well.

As opposed to that Miracle Whip spot. 

Which tested well above Norms.


Norm. Singular.











 

Wednesday, November 11, 2026

Part the Seventh, of Twelve.


In my subterranean office I have about a dozen replicas of notebooks of famous thinkers from years past.

A small publisher in Barcelona, Knonecker Wallis, publishes reprints some of these notebooks and charges handsomely for them. In about a year, they go out of print, and I wish I had bought two copies.

Here are a few pages and the cover from Isaac Newton's college notebooks. You can browse them on this site from Cambridge University. 

I can't say I understand anything here but that doesn't matter. They show the flow of ideas, the cross-outs, the hard-work of actual thought. All that is marked down so it can be thought about, remembered, re-worked like a tough Saturday crossword. That's the point.

Thinking.





Here are a few other examples.

Just like in real-life the Turing one is clipped together with the kind of clips I last used in seventh grade. They didn't work for Turing. They didn't work for twelve-year-old me, they don't work any better now. Open the Turing a few pages and the things breaks apart.

That's part of its charm.







Johnnie von Neumann was the genius who intimidated all the other geniuses. By the age of six he could divide eight-digit numbers in his head. By eight he had mastered calculus. He even knew the word dumb had a b in it.


This is von Neumann's blueprint for an early computer.



I like note books like these--and I have half a dozen more--because while I don't understand what's being deciphered in them, it helps me to see the very act of deciphering.

Too many people, especially those who grew up with sophisticated digital tools like those we use so readily today, think work springs fully formed like Athena from Zeus' head. 
They start designing and 'word smithing' before they have the vaguest idea down. They refuse to acknowledge that many of the greatest discoveries of human-kind--from the very beginnings of human-kind--radiated from the simple human act of making a mistake, taking a wrong turn, talking your way out of a jam, or getting lost.

From an evolutionary point of view, finding yourself in a fix has always lead to ingenuity, risk taking, rolling the dice and finding something magical.

As Ogden Nash wrote...


In other words, the termite got where she got by mistake. Most living things do.

The Shibboleths of our era prize speed and efficiency. They'll put up with a Library of Congress' -worth of AI slop from a NASA's-worth of computer brains so long as it's fast and cheap and meaningless, and for the most part, insulting. 99.78-percent of everything we read and heard uttered, regardless of the medium or the speaker, is "a tale told by an idiot, full of sound and fury, signifying nothing." 99.78-percent of what we read today makes the Gilligan's Island Christmas Special look like "Hamlet."



There's no guarantee that pencil and pad will reduce the amount of crap in the world. I'd guess Bulwer-Lytton wrote this archetypical drivel with pen in hand. So hand-work is not guarantor of quality.


Robert Caro, two-time winner of both the National Book Award and the Pulitzer-Prize, told a story about slowing down his writing. While at Princeton, he would wait till the last moment to write for his fiction class.

Though Caro always got A's, his professor R.P. Blackmur, encouraged Caro to slow down.

Writing, drawing, doodling by hand forced Caro to slow down--to not think with his fingers.


When Caro interviews people, he follows similar "slow down" guidance. 

Much of the decline of nearly everything is because we have so much to do we believe nothing is worth our time. 

The truth is, however, whether or not people know for sure whether the messages you or brands send to them are made by humans or machines, they may very well sense how they are being treated.

Very few people are gulled by a dirty carpet at 
an understaffed hotel front desk that says "elite" on it.


Most people, most creatives, most agencies, most of the world are treated like a pothole on the way to enormous profits. Caring, craft, time, pencilling get in the way of ever-more Mammon.

I remember years ago a story I read about Bill Bernbach. It's said a client said to him, "Why do you spend so much time on copy? Nobody reads it."

Bernbach is said to have answered, "Ten percent of people read copy. That's who I write it for."

The best way to be a human is to care about other humans who care.


                            Photos by Christopher Payne.