This Humanment might seem more of a joke than a firm principle. People have been writing in symbols since the Lascaux caves about 22,000 years ago, around the last time anyone anywhere did something honest. Picture writing was all the rage among the Pharaonic-set, and for longer than most people can fathom Cuneiform was the lingua franca of the civilized world.
There's nothing, really, inherently wrong with symbolic writing. The leap to alphabets involved symbols too. Only symbols of phonemes--sounds--rather than objects. Rather than a sketch of an ibis, we drew shapes that could represent the sound the word ibis.
The problem I have with emojis can be found--as most things can--within Orwell's great essays, "Politics and the English Language." In that piece which, if you care at all about honest communication you will read, print out, and save on your hard-drive, Orwell lists six rules for good writing. They don't precisely link up to emojis, but give me a few seconds to explain why I make the connection.
In his 1949 novel, Nineteen Eighty-four, Orwell creates a language called Newspeak. To limit a person's ability to think critically, Newspeak restricts vocabulary, limiting people's ability to articulate with nuance and express abstract concepts. In his appendix (the part of a book, not your anatomy) Newspeak is characterized by a continually diminished vocabulary and contractions. (Not child-birth contractions. Think cognates like Gestapo, Ice, Maga and Doge.)
Limited vocabulary results in limited expressions. Much of today's epidemic of outrage comes from the population no longer having strata of words that allow an escalation toward anger or violence. In many walks of life we move quickly from:
'I disagree' to
'I hate you' to
'I'm going to kill you, muthafukker.'
That's every fight I've ever had with a cab-driver or every subway contretemps I've ever witnessed and run from.
That is trumpism in thirteen or fourteen words, depending on whether or not you consider muthafukker one or two words.
Here is one more example:
'I believe we should tax trillionaires' to
'You Sharia-law-amerikkla-hating communist' to
'Insurrection in Washington.'
Emojis, to be clear, are not the stain of trumpism. But they are a high-occupancy-vehicle lane on the superhighway to Newspeak.
Going back to Orwell's first rule above, 'Never use a metaphor, simile or other figure of speech which you are used to seeing in print' we are all too used to seeing praying hands, smiles, piles of shit in our communications. If you want to really get through to readers, you might work a little harder and try to be interesting rather than expected.
I worked, briefly with a talented art-director for a time who had but two words to describe an idea he liked, "sick," or "dope."
After a day working with him, I went home looking for a methadone clinic.
Herman Kahn, a 1960's-era physicist, military-strategist and employee of the RAND Corporation, created a 44-step escalation ladder to help the world avert nuclear war. Imagine, in a time of limited political skill, intelligence, historical language and thinking, how many fewer steps there might be today before missiles or drones start flying. Someone might, for instance, start a war so people don't find out he raped 14-year-olds.
Of all the inhuman things humans can do, using an emoji or an occasional LOL aren't really that egregious.
This Humanment is included as a warning.
To watch our words.
To understand their power.
To think about how to use them for effect.
And to be mindful of what happens when we stop questioning the meaning behind language and how it is used. From Newspeak, to Goebbel's (and roy cohn's and trump's) Big Lie, to Lingua Tertii Imperium, Viktor Klemperer's great book on the malevolent use of language in Nazi Germany, then Soviet Germany, to be human is to question.
And questioning takes thoughtful examination and expression. As Klemperer reminds us, "resistance to oppression (political or employment or marital) begins by questioning the constant use of 'buzzwords.' Think about phrases like 'the Patriot Act,' 'Agentic,' (software replacing people) or such strident bushwa as this, 'WPP Open turns marketing into a continuous engine for growth. Powered by AI agents that work across your entire marketing process, connected by shared intelligence and guided by world-class talent.'
Thou Shalt Not Emoji because Thou Shalt Think.👏




No comments:
Post a Comment