Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Part the Tenth of Twelve.

As readers of this blog might know, I read a lot.

I've been reading a lot since I was thirteen and in ninth grade. Mrs. Chapin, a teacher who saved my life, realized something was wrong with me. I wasn't normal, she concluded. Quickly, and without checking with the "administration," or my parents, or even me, she sent me to the school's well-booked library. 

"Just pick out books and read," Mrs. Chapin instructed. "It doesn't matter what. Just read."

The first book I selected was John Hersey's "Hirsoshima," which was the entire issue of "The New Yorker" when the magazine published it on August 31, 1946--fifty-four weeks after "Little Boy" was dropped above the city, killing, almost instantaneously 140,000 people. (Imagine naming the most destructive force known to mankind "Little Boy." That's like calling an entire category of ballistic missiles, 'defensive weapons.' Mosquito netting is defensive. Nuclear weapons are not.)

I read and read and read.

The best way to read

Widely and randomly.

Fifty-six years later, I can still hear the imperative of Mrs. Chapin. "Just pick out books and read." 

Back in early 2021, I read a review--in either the Times of the Journal--of this book, below. By that time, my wife and I had bought our small ramshackle-ness by the sea on the Gingham Coast, and after a lifetime of thinking that the entirety of the world's avian spectrum was pigeons, I started notice birds.


Especially, I noticed large birds of prey. The rare bald eagle, and from around late March through September up on the Connecticut littoral, the majestic and plentiful ospreys that nest everywhere. All spring and summer you can see them making purposeful circles in the sky, then swoop down, talons first, into the sea, making off with a small squirmy fish to bring back to their little ones. I used to play sports and I used to watch sports. I've never seen any sports action as exciting as the osprey or as athletic and deft.

So, following Mrs. Chapin's edict, I bought "A World on the Wing," and proceeded to devour it like I was an osprey and it was a baby menhaden.


Here's the bit that's stayed with me for five years, and the subject of today's Humanment: Thou Shalt Beware of Dogma.


In "Wing," I remembered this passage. To my mind, it illuminates the many reasons behind today radical-right anti-expert-ism, aka "the death of expertise." With everybody believing nothing--even doubting whether the earth is round, or if climate-change is real, though we can see it with our own ears. 

“You know what bothers me about scientists?” my mother asked some years ago. “They always say, ‘We used to think, but now we know.’ ” If I remember correctly, she was ticked off over some flip-flopping research about diet and health, maybe the endless eggs-are-good/ eggs-are-bad debate, but I have to admit, she had a point. Science is a process, one where ideas are proposed, tested, and discarded if new evidence demands it. Any good researcher (if they’re being true to the scientific method) ought to say, “We used to think, but now we think.” Of course, human nature doesn’t work that way. Even scientists tend to look for certainty, and often put their trust in the latest, sexiest research to be published, tacitly assuming it’s the final word on a subject.”

Much of today's professional disdain for advertising stems from, I think, the pseudo-scientists of advertising reducing advertising to an if-then proposition and a set of "best-practices." Through this furiously spurious legerdemain, they promised results they couldn't deliver and never will--including the very idea that advertising can be measurable at all. This is the very basis for the capture and extraction of the ad industry by the well-MBA'd technocrats who attend conferences and podium-ize and lanyard and pontificate about how to reach people, though they never have, except into their pockets.

Nobel Prize-winner, not donald tump, but Czezłow Miłosz, overheard an ancient Galician Jew say the quote below in his book "The Captive Mind." I wish all the nimrods wearing this hat--or supporting nimrod-ism-ness would consider it and the horros of ignoring the quotation.


I apologize for this monstrosity.


There are millions of people now acting as the willing executioners of the new "always right" dogma machine: AI. I ask you, if AI is so good, why are closed-captions--which should be easy--wrong about 91-percent of the time? Why is everything wrong about 91-percent of the time.

Our job as humans is guard against dogma.

After all, this dogma don't bark.

The more someone tells us something is so, the more we must say, 'prove it.'

At least that's what I think now.







No comments: